Trends in Cognitive Sciences
ReviewThe biological basis of language: insight from developmental grammatical impairments
Section snippets
Developmental disorders as a window into the biology of language
Given the lack of animal models for language, and the inability to use invasive procedures with humans except out of medical necessity, our knowledge of the neurobiology of language has long depended upon natural experiments. During the 19th and 20th centuries, studies of patients with acquired brain lesions provided key insights 1, 2, 3. Understanding of language in the 21st century promises to be enriched by data from developmental disorders. SLI, a family of language impairments in otherwise
Grammatical phenotypes of SLI
This review focuses on what G-SLI can reveal about the structure and neural instantiation of language. Crucially, G-SLI is not a global impairment of language or even of grammar, but is strongly manifested in certain aspects of linguistic performance while leaving others largely intact. This raises the possibility that the contrast reflects a key division within the neural or genetic substrates of language. In particular, children with G-SLI have difficulty interpreting and producing syntactic
Extended versus Basic syntax
Extended syntax involves hierarchical structures and dependencies between words, often spanning the entire clause, which are computed in real time. For example, in ‘wh’-questions such as ‘Who did Joe see __?’, the ‘wh’-word and the empty position after ‘see’ are in a dependent relation, which may be analyzed as the movement of the word from its original position in an underlying structure (Figure 1). Additionally, Extended syntax is abstract: the assembly and interpretation of phrases depend on
Extended versus Basic morphology
G-SLI also impairs morphology in a selective fashion which targets abstract combinatorial operations. Extended morphological objects are generated, perceived, and represented as combinations of two or more morphemes, whereas Basic ones are stored and retrieved as wholes, or at best as containing parts which do not freely combine with other parts 9, 10. For example, in English, irregular past-tense forms (‘ate’, ‘bought’) are basic and handled by memory, whereas regular past-tense forms
Neural substrates of the distinction between Basic and Extended grammar
Recent advances using electroencephalography (EEG), magnetoencephalography (MEG), functional MRI (fMRI), and diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) tractography have led to sophisticated new models of the neural organization of language 35, 43, 44, 45. They allow us to assess whether the Extended processes, which pose the greatest problems in G-SLI, implicate brain networks that are different from those supporting Basic processes.
Neuroanatomy
A recent meta-analysis of 25 studies of the neuroanatomical correlates of broad SLI revealed consistent structural anomalies in two regions: the frontal cortex, particularly Broca's area and its right-hemisphere homologue, and the caudate nucleus [56]. The findings are generally consistent with SLI being a deficit of Extended processing (though Broca's area participates in aspects of Basic syntax and probably Basic morphology as well). The heterogeneity of SLI may mean that any meta-analysis of
Concluding remarks
We have suggested that the study of language impairment has opened a new frontier of research which promises a comprehensive biological understanding of language, from evolution and genes, through neuroanatomy and neural function, to linguistic computation, and thence to overt speech and comprehension. These advances depend on a multi-level approach. Rather than mapping genetic variants directly to overall language impairment, researchers must characterize the intermediate links by probing for
Acknowledgments
This paper is a capstone to the research of Heather van der Lely, who died of cancer in February, 2014. She identified the grammatical subtype of SLI, characterized it empirically (with collaborators in London, Paris, Louvain la Neuve, and Berlin), proposed the Extended–Basic distinction to explain the pattern of deficits, and wrote the first draft of this paper. Steven Pinker rewrote and fact-checked the paper before and after Heather's death, with extensive input from her main collaborator
References (83)
Domain-specific cognitive systems: insight from Grammatical-SLI
Trends Cogn. Sci.
(2005)- et al.
A grammatical specific language impairment in children: an autosomal dominant inheritance?
Brain Lang.
(1996) Processing limitations and the grammatical profile of children with specific language impairment
Adv. Child Dev. Behav.
(2007)- et al.
Is the movement deficit in syntactic SLI related to traces or to thematic role transfer?
Brain Lang.
(2007) Specifically language impaired and normally developing children: verbal passive vs adjectival passive sentence interpretation
Lingua
(1996)Evidence for a grammar-specific deficit in children
Curr. Biol.
(1998)- et al.
The past and future of the past tense
Trends Cogn. Sci.
(2002) - et al.
A challenge to current models of past tense inflection: the impact of phonotactics
Cognition
(2006) Pathways to language: fiber tracts in the human brain
Trends Cogn. Sci.
(2009)The cortical language circuit: from auditory perception to sentence comprehension
Trends Cogn. Sci.
(2012)
Localization of the syntactic mismatch negativity in the temporal cortex: an MEG study
Neuroimage
Towards a neural basis of auditory sentence processing
Trends Cogn. Sci.
An anterior-posterior gradient of cognitive control within the dorsomedial striatum
Neuroimage
Contributions of memory circuits to language: the declarative/procedural model
Cognition
Abstract grammatical processing of nouns and verbs in Broca's area: evidence from fMRI
Cortex
Temporal and frontal systems in speech comprehension: An fMRI study of past tense processing
Neuropsychologia
Children with specific language impairment: the role of prosodic processes in explaining difficulties in processing syntactic information
Brain Res.
CMIP and ATP2C2 modulate phonological short-term memory in language impairment
Am. J. Hum. Genet.
Comprehension of reversible relative clauses in specifically language impaired and normally developing Greek children
Brain Lang.
Who did Buzz see someone? Grammaticality judgement of wh-questions in typically developing children and children with Grammatical-SLI
Lingua
Remarques sur le siege de la faculte du languge articule suivies d’une observation d/aphemie (parte de la parole)
Bull. Soc. Anat. Paris
Der aphasischa symotomen complex
Specializations of the human brain
Sci. Am.
Language in autism
The interface between ADHD and language impairment: an examination of language, achievement, and cognitive processing
J. Child Psychol. Psychiatry
Deciphering the genetic basis of speech and language disorders
Annu. Rev. Neurosci.
Recent advances in the genetics of language impairment
Genome Med.
Assessing component language deficits in the early detection of reading difficulty risk
J. Learn. Disabil.
Grammatical-specific language impairment: A window onto domain specificity
Does impaired grammatical comprehension provide evidence for an innate grammar module?
Appl. Psycholing.
Tense over time: the longitudinal course of tense acquisition in children with Specific Language Impairment
J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
German impaired grammar: the clause structure revisited
Lang. Acquis.
Production and comprehension of pronouns by Greek children with specific language impairment
Br. J. Dev. Psychol.
The Algebraic Mind
Words and Rules: The Ingredients of Language
The Minimalist Program
Electrical brain responses in language-impaired children reveal grammar-specific deficits
PLoS ONE
Number dissimilarities facilitate the comprehension of relative clauses in children with (Grammatical) Specific Language Impairment
J. Child Lang.
On-line processing of wh-questions in children with G-SLI and typically developing children
Int. J. Lang. Commun. Disord.
Grammatical tense deficits in children with SLI and nonspecific language impairment: relationships with nonverbal IQ over time
J. Speech Lang. Hear. Res.
The production of inflectional morphology in hereditary specific language impairment
Appl. Psycholinguist.
Cited by (61)
Music skills of Spanish-speaking children with developmental language disorder
2023, Research in Developmental DisabilitiesHow did language evolve in the lineage of higher primates?
2021, LinguaCitation Excerpt :Independent of the type of linguistic information, top-down driven attentive or more conscious computations seem to take place in the posterior temporoparietal region and computed via the dorsal streams (e.g., Pillay et al., 2017; Matchin and Hickok, 2020). In contrast, local phrase structures, agent-first strategies, predefined syntactic templates (treelets) and basic semantic information are transferred ventral via the uncinate fasciculus from the superior and/or middle temporal gyrus to the frontal operculum and Broca’s region involving BAs 45 & 47 (Van der Lely and Pinker, 2014; DeWitt and Rauschecker, 2012). In sum, ml-CC cannot be located in specific cortical regions but can be associated with different subcortico-cortical circuits.
Cognitive Development: Neurobiological Foundations and Contemporary Directions
2020, Encyclopedia of Infant and Early Childhood DevelopmentIndividual Differences in Language Acquisition and Processing
2018, Trends in Cognitive SciencesCitation Excerpt :In acquisition, the formal approach assumes the existence of abstract innate knowledge of language at birth (i.e., linguistic principles), coupled with formal computational machinery that enables structure building. This constitutes universal grammar (UG), which historically has only been predicted to be subject to IDs in exceptional cases (e.g., neurocognitive disorders [14]). However, recent proposals incorporate concepts that may predict IDs.
Evaluating Part v of the German version of the Token Test as a screening of specific language impairment in preschoolers
2020, Applied PsycholinguisticsThe neuroanatomy of developmental language disorder: a systematic review and meta-analysis
2024, Nature Human Behaviour